In August 2020, in an opinion column I wrote in Adelaide, I pointed to a comparison that almost nobody outside higher education ever talks about:
"While a local might pay about $7,000 a year for a nursing degree, an international student will fork out $36,000. This income is creating local jobs and improving the quality of education at our universities."
At the time, the country was in the middle of a heated pandemic border debate. Federal and state governments were tentatively exploring pilot flights to bring back a small cohort of continuing students to South Australia, and public sentiment was sharply divided. My argument in print was simple and direct: international students are not a burden on the state; they are an economic pillar creating local jobs and directly subsidising our public institutions.
Six years on, that gap has not closed. It has widened, for a reason almost nobody noticed at the time. Yet in the endless parliamentary debates, Senate inquiries, and media headlines about international student caps and migration numbers, it remains the single fact nobody in authority wants to mention.
Two Students, One Lecture Hall
Picture two nineteen-year-olds walking into an 8:00 AM lecture in anatomy and physiology at an Australian university.
They sit in the same tiered auditorium. They listen to the same professor explain the circulatory system. They read from the same syllabus, log into the same digital learning portal, and take the same clinical placement shifts alongside registered nurses in the same metropolitan public hospital.
When the census date passes, the domestic student incurs a Commonwealth-supported contribution of $4,738 for a full year of nursing, largely deferred through HECS-HELP. The international student next to them receives an invoice of roughly $35,000 or more, payable in cash each semester.
That domestic figure is worth pausing on, because it is not the number I quoted in 2020. Back then a nursing student paid around $7,000. From 2021 the Job-ready Graduates package moved nursing into the lowest contribution band, cutting it by roughly a third to encourage people into the profession. A sensible policy, and I have no argument with it. But it means the ratio I described in print has quietly stretched from roughly five to one to something closer to seven to one, while almost all of the public debate since has proceeded as though international students were becoming a smaller part of the picture rather than a larger one.
Over a three-year undergraduate nursing qualification, that arithmetic widens into a chasm. The domestic student's total direct contribution comes to a little over $14,000. The international student pays roughly $105,000 or more.
The obvious question — the one that should be at the centre of every national conversation about tertiary policy — is: where does that ninety-thousand-dollar difference actually go?
It certainly does not go toward giving the international student a seven-times-better seat, a seven-times-better textbook, or dedicated luxury facilities. It does not buy them smaller tutorial sizes or specialised academic attention. In practice, the educational product delivered to both students is identical.
The difference goes to keeping the institution itself alive.
The Architecture of the Subsidy
The general public largely assumes that Australian public universities are funded by the Australian public.
Four decades ago, that was largely true. In the late 1980s, direct Commonwealth funding accounted for the overwhelming majority of university operating revenues. Since then, successive governments of both political stripes have steadily engineered a quiet retreat. Through changes to the Commonwealth Grant Scheme (CGS), freezes in indexation, and real-term cuts to research block funding, public funding per student has steadily declined in real terms.
To fill that widening fiscal void without raising domestic tuition fees to politically toxic American levels, Australian universities turned to the only lever they were permitted to pull without government price caps: the global student market.
The math is not subtle. The profit margins on full-fee-paying international students do not merely cover the cost of teaching them. They cross-subsidise: 1. Domestic teaching deficits: For dozens of critical domestic degrees — particularly in science, nursing, teaching, and humanities — government contributions combined with student fees frequently fail to meet the actual per-student delivery cost. 2. Unfunded academic research: Australia’s national research output, which determines our global university rankings, is heavily underfunded by competitive public research grants. The gap between what a research grant pays and what an advanced laboratory actually costs to run is overwhelmingly funded by international student margins. 3. Campus infrastructure: The lecture theatres, simulation labs, libraries, and IT infrastructure used every day by domestic students have been overwhelmingly financed by surplus revenues from overseas enrolments.
Without that international cross-subsidy, Australian universities would face a brutal choice: drastically raise domestic HECS contributions, massively cut course offerings, shut regional campuses, or accept an immediate, precipitous collapse in the quality of domestic education.
The Fragility of the Model
In 2020, making this argument was an urgent defense of common sense against xenophobic knee-jerk impulses to keep borders hermetically sealed. If South Australia shut its doors indefinitely, universities would shed thousands of staff, local businesses would go under, and the domestic higher education offering would deteriorate.
That was the immediate economic case. But writing from the vantage point of 2026, there is an uncomfortable second half to the argument that 2020-me could not write, but that today's reality demands:
A higher education system that relies on a seven-fold cross-subsidy from private foreign families to sustain its basic public mission is fundamentally fragile.
Over the past three years, the Australian university sector has experienced the inevitable whiplash of this design flaw. When the federal government abruptly tightened student visa approvals under Ministerial Direction 107 and moved to impose blunt national enrolment caps, university balance sheets across the country did not merely tighten — they shuddered.
Regional and mid-tier universities that had relied on international fee margins found themselves facing immediate hiring freezes, department closures, and curriculum gutting. Vice-chancellors were forced into public panic because their baseline operational viability was tethered to a private market they could neither control nor protect from sovereign political risk.
Using international students as an unacknowledged fiscal balancing item was always a precarious gamble. It turned universities into export corporations with degree-granting charters. It incentivised marketing departments to prioritise volume and revenue over student experience and graduate outcomes. And it created a dangerous dependency where any shift in visa processing, geopolitics, or global currency rates threatens the solvency of public teaching.
Calling the Bluff
Saying that the cross-subsidy is fragile is not an argument against international students. It is an argument for policy honesty.
For thirty years, Australian policymakers have enjoyed the benefits of a world-class university system without paying for it. They have boasted about Australia’s top-50 global university rankings, celebrated national research breakthroughs, and kept domestic tertiary education accessible, all while allowing public funding per domestic student to wither.
They did this because international students picked up the tab.
When politicians stand up today and claim that international students are a burden on national infrastructure or a drain on local services, they are playing a cynical double game. The very lecture halls their domestic constituents learn in, the laboratories discovering new medical treatments, and the local hospital shifts being staffed by nursing graduates exist because international students paid several times the domestic rate to be there.
If Australia wants to cap international numbers, change migration settings, or alter the character of its campuses, it has every sovereign right to do so. But it must be honest about the invoice.
If you remove the international cross-subsidy, you must either replace it with substantial public tax revenue, or you must tell domestic Australian families that their children’s university degrees are about to become vastly more expensive and substantially worse in quality.
There is no third option. The arithmetic has not changed since 2020. It has only become impossible to ignore.
The 2026 student contribution figure for nursing is the Commonwealth's own: see the Department of Education's [2026 indexed rates](https://www.education.gov.au/download/19201/2026-indexed-rates/41481/document/pdf), which sets the maximum student contribution for nursing at $4,738. International nursing fees vary by institution; check the published schedule of the university in question rather than relying on a sector average.