Of all the sentences in an opinion column I wrote in August 2020, there was one that made people visibly uncomfortable:
"One only needs to look at comments on social media to know that many South Australians consider international students akin to refugees. The perception is that we are doing them a favour by allowing them to study here. Nothing could be further from the truth."
It was a blunt observation, but anyone who spent ten minutes reading the comments section under any news report about international students during the pandemic knew it was accurate. The prevailing tone was not one of economic deliberation. It was one of patronising disbelief: Why are these people demanding to come here? Don’t they understand we are doing them a favour by letting them in?
Six years later, the pandemic has faded into history, but the underlying sentiment has not softened. If anything, it has hardened, migrating from social media comment threads into the centre of mainstream Australian political discourse. In debates over rental vacancy rates, migration caps, and university funding, international students are still routinely discussed as though their presence in this country is an act of generous national hospitality that has been abused.
It is worth asking why this perception is so persistent, so bipartisan, and so uniquely applied to this one industry.
The Invisibility of Onshore Exports
Consider an analogy. When a cargo vessel carrying 150,000 tonnes of iron ore leaves Port Hedland bound for a steel mill in Qingdao, nobody in Australia suggests we are doing China a favour. When a container ship loaded with Barossa Shiraz or prime Australian beef docks in Singapore, no one remarks on our profound benevolence in permitting overseas consumers to drink our wine or eat our produce.
We understand instinctively that these are commercial transactions. A customer overseas wanted a high-quality product, Australian producers supplied it, the customer paid a market price, and Australian businesses banked the revenue. We treat our resource and agricultural exporters with immense civic pride.
International education is Australia’s fourth-largest export industry, generating tens of billions of dollars annually in export revenue and supporting hundreds of thousands of local jobs. Yet almost nobody thinks of it as an export.
The reason is a psychological accident of geography: education is an onshore export.
Unlike coal, wheat, or gas, which are produced domestically and shipped overseas to be consumed elsewhere, international education requires the consumer to travel to the point of production. The student must physically live in Adelaide, Melbourne, or Brisbane for three or four years. They ride our buses, shop in our supermarkets, sit in our coffee shops, and rent our apartments.
Because the international student is physically present, the public evaluates them through the cognitive lens of domestic population and immigration, rather than the lens of international trade. To the average citizen, an international student does not look like an export invoice. They look like another commuter competing for a seat on the train, or another applicant standing in a queue for a rental inspection on a Saturday morning.
The export benefit is invisible; the domestic presence is visible. The result is a profound cognitive disconnect: Australia celebrates the billions of dollars deposited into our economy, while treating the individuals who brought that money with them as recipients of our charity.
The Reality of the Ledger
If you strip away the political rhetoric and look strictly at the ledger, the idea that Australia is doing international students a "favour" collapses immediately.
An international student arriving in Australia does not receive a gift. They enter into a demanding, expensive, and legally enforceable commercial contract.
Before they set foot in a classroom, they or their families have paid tens of thousands of dollars in tuition fees upfront — typically several times what a domestic student pays for the identical course. They have purchased mandatory private Overseas Student Health Cover (OSHC) to ensure they do not access Medicare. They have paid visa application charges that now sit among the most expensive on earth.
Once they arrive, they spend roughly $30,000 or more a year on living expenses — money that flows directly into the cash registers of local grocers, landlords, public transit systems, utilities, and retail stores. To support themselves, they take on shifts in aged-care facilities, convenience stores, restaurant kitchens, and logistics hubs — often working the anti-social hours and high-turnover jobs that domestic workers avoid. On the wages they earn from those shifts, they pay income tax, while remaining entirely ineligible for social security, JobSeeker, or public housing.
This is not a story of foreign privilege or national benevolence. It is a story of paying customers who contribute substantial net capital and essential labour to the Australian economy, and who take almost nothing out of the public safety net in return.
The Cost of the "Favour" Mentality
Treating international students as beneficiaries of our goodwill is not just patronising; it is economically self-destructive.
When a country convinces itself that it is doing its export customers a favour, it stops treating them like customers. It stops worrying about quality of delivery. It assumes that because Australia is sunny, safe, and speaks English, international students will continue arriving regardless of how they are spoken about in parliament or treated at the border.
It breeds an intellectual complacency in our universities, which have too often treated international fee revenue as a guaranteed entitlement rather than something that must be earned every single day through world-class teaching, genuine pastoral care, and real industry pathways.
And most dangerously, it poisons our civic culture. It allows politicians to blame international students for decades of domestic policy failures in housing supply, infrastructure planning, and university funding. It turns paying guests into convenient scapegoats.
International education is not a charitable outreach program. It is a world-class service industry built on a partnership of mutual self-interest. Australia provides high-calibre qualifications, safety, and global opportunities; international students bring capital, hard work, cultural vibrancy, and global connections.
The moment we stop pretending we are doing them a favour is the moment we can finally start having an adult conversation about the future of the sector.