Skip to content
Aashish Wagley

International education

Quality Is the Only Competitive Advantage That Actually Lasts

A 2019 reflection on the UK's International Education Strategy, rising Asian competition, and discounting dressed up as scholarships.

Aashish Wagley2 min read

Back in 2019, the UK unveiled a new International Education Strategy built around a fairly bold pair of numbers: grow international student numbers by 30% and lift the sector's economic impact to £35 billion annually by 2030. It was framed, as government strategies tend to be framed, in maximalist terms — aimed at cementing the country's status as a world leader in education just as it prepared to leave the EU.

I remember reading that announcement and thinking mainly about what it left out. A growth target alone, however ambitious, was never going to be the interesting part of the story. The more interesting part was what was already happening quietly to the competitive landscape underneath it.

By 2019, the traditional picture of international education — a handful of English-speaking Western destinations competing gently among themselves for the world's students — was already out of date. More than the usual "Asian tigers" had emerged as serious competition and a genuine threat to the traditionally dominant Western destinations, and Chinese universities were appearing in global rankings with a frequency that would have been unthinkable a decade earlier.

Against that backdrop, a strategy built mainly around growth numbers, underpinned largely by post-study work rights, a favourable exchange rate, and migration pathways, struck me as fragile rather than strong. Australia and Canada, at the time, were growing for exactly those reasons — the return on investment for a student who could work during and after study, and the migration pathway waiting at the end of it. What I was already noticing on the ground was something less visible in any strategy document: Australian universities increasingly discounting tuition through what were technically labelled "scholarships," largely in response to competition from private institutions and to cushion the impact of funding cuts. Because headline fees in Australia remained genuinely high compared to the UK, US and Canada, those discounts looked less like a temporary promotion and more like a structural feature that was here to stay.

That kind of practice eventually compresses quality and services, whatever the growth numbers say in the short term. It shows up first in student welfare services, then in retention and attrition rates — problems that ripple outward to affect students, their families, agents, institutions, communities, states and, eventually, a country's international reputation. A country doesn't tarnish its standing in this sector through one scandal. It tarnishes it gradually, through institutions behaving irresponsibly at scale while a headline growth number keeps climbing regardless.

When every competing nation is strategising and re-strategising for the next decade of international student mobility, the real competitive advantage was never going to be who could offer the deepest discount or the most generous work rights. It was always going to be quality education that genuinely adds value to a student's future, backed by quality services, a responsible industry, and regulation strong enough to make irresponsible behaviour actually cost something. Everything else is a strategy for winning a number. Only that combination is a strategy for keeping a reputation.