Skip to content
Aashish Wagley

International education

Now That a Degree Is a Commodity, No Wonder

A 2018 reflection on the early signs of international education treating a degree as a transaction.

Aashish Wagley2 min read

I remember coming across an unusual post from an education provider several years ago that has stuck with me since. It announced, in so many words, that the provider was now officially selling diplomas, bachelor's degrees and master's degrees in a particular subject. Maybe "selling" was simply the wrong word choice by someone who meant "offering." Maybe it wasn't. Either way, the fact that the sentence could be written and published without anyone involved flinching at it told me something worth paying attention to.

A great deal isn't happening right in international education, in Australia and in plenty of other parts of the world, and most of it traces back to the same root cause: treating education primarily as a transaction rather than as what it actually is. The sector was growing briskly at the time, and growth has a way of making everyone involved forget what the thing being sold actually means. Education isn't just numbers and dollars on a spreadsheet. It's one of the more sensitive and consequential decisions a person or a family will ever make, and quality has to be treated as paramount, not as a variable to be optimised once growth targets are already locked in.

The economic tailwinds propping up Australia's international education sector at the time — a strong dollar, the ability to earn income while studying, and a migration pathway waiting at the end of a degree — were never going to be permanent advantages on their own. Other countries were developing rapidly, and their currencies and opportunities were becoming more competitive by the year. The same transition that hollowed out manufacturing and services jobs in developed economies, moving them to developing ones that could do the work more competitively, was always going to be possible in international education too, once the underlying advantage stopped being quality and started being mainly price and migration access.

That's why I think this needs attention at every level, not just from regulators after the fact. Every stakeholder in this sector — institutions, agents, governments, and the students and families the whole system exists to serve — has a role in identifying problems honestly, discussing them openly, and improving the sector before market forces do it for everyone, the hard way. The students at the centre of all of it are simultaneously the most valuable part of the sector and, if the incentives are allowed to drift far enough from education and toward selling, the most vulnerable.